The Best Local Foods to Eat in New York

Table of contents:

The Best Local Foods to Eat in New York

Ready to learn more about The Best Local Foods to Eat in New York to get a taste of my experience there?

If you’re eager to explore the culinary landscape of the Big Apple, you’re in for a treat! New York City is a hub of exquisite local cuisine, featuring everything from classic New York-style pizza to savory deli sandwiches. Allow me to guide you through the top local dishes that define New York’s food scene. It’s time to get ready for a delicious adventure through the city’s most beloved eats.

New York-style pizza is a must-try, with its thin crust, rich tomato sauce, and gooey mozzarella cheese. It’s a simple yet perfect representation of the city’s fast-paced lifestyle, allowing you to grab a slice on the go. Another staple is the bagel, often topped with cream cheese and lox, showcasing New York’s Jewish culinary heritage. For a truly New York experience, visit an established deli like Katz’s Delicatessen and sink your teeth into a pastrami on rye – an iconic sandwich known for its spiced, smoked meat.

Don’t forget to sample some street food as well. Food trucks and carts offer an array of choices, such as hot dogs from Nathan’s Famous, which have been a city favorite since 1916. For dessert, indulge in a New York-style cheesecake, rich, creamy, and often cited as the best rendition of this classic dessert.

Each dish mentioned is not just food; it’s a piece of New York’s identity, reflecting the city’s diverse culture and history. Enjoying these foods is akin to taking a bite out of New York itself. So, whether you’re dining at a renowned pizzeria in Manhattan or a quaint bagel shop in Brooklyn, you’re experiencing the very essence of the city. Bon appétit!


In New York, the variety of pizza available is impressive, with offerings sure to delight even the most refined tastes. This city is famous for its pizza, and residents are passionate about their local pizza culture. New York’s pizza scene showcases an extensive array of toppings and some of the finest pizzerias on the planet, providing a unique pizza experience.

Brooklyn’s Di Fara Pizza is a standout in the New York pizza landscape. Open since 1964, this esteemed establishment is run by Dom DeMarco, a master of pizza who painstakingly prepares each pie with fresh, quality ingredients and achieves a perfectly thin and crisp crust. Di Fara caters to all preferences, offering traditional toppings like pepperoni and cheese as well as gourmet choices such as artichoke hearts and arugula.

For another quintessential New York pizza experience, Joe’s Pizza in Greenwich Village is a location not to be missed. Since 1975, Joe’s Pizza has been a beloved part of the city’s pizza tradition. Their pizzas are known for their straightforward yet delicious taste, featuring a harmonious blend of tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, and a touch of basil. The crust is expertly thin and bears a slight char, providing a satisfying crunch with every bite. The enduring popularity of Joe’s Pizza among aficionados is a testament to its quality.

Each of these pizzerias demonstrates the excellence and dedication to pizza-making that New York is known for, making them revered destinations for anyone seeking a true taste of the city’s pizza.


After enjoying the rich taste of New York-style pizza, it’s worth turning our attention to another beloved local specialty: New York bagels. Renowned for their unique texture and variety, these bagels stand out as a culinary highlight in the city. The assortment of flavors ranges from the simple, such as plain and sesame, to the bold, like ‘everything’ and cinnamon raisin, ensuring a match for any palate.

For those with a penchant for classic tastes, plain bagels with a generous spread of cream cheese are a staple. Adventurous eaters might gravitate towards ‘everything’ bagels or the innovative ‘everything but the bagel’ seasoning. On the sweeter side, cinnamon raisin bagels offer a delightful combination of spice and sweetness.

Toppings for these round delights are only limited by your imagination. Some prefer the traditional route with cream cheese, while others may layer on smoked salmon, often referred to as lox, with avocado for a richer experience. A bagel sandwich, complete with smoked salmon, capers, and red onion, presents a more substantial meal.

New York City’s bagels are an essential experience for connoisseurs and casual food enthusiasts alike. Delve into this quintessential New York delicacy and understand why they’ve earned such a distinguished reputation.

Hot Dogs

As someone who lives in New York, I highly recommend trying a New York hot dog for anyone visiting. New York City is known for its hot dogs, with a long history and a thriving street food scene.

You should definitely visit Gray’s Papaya, an iconic hot dog stand that’s been around since 1973. They serve hot dogs that are grilled just right, with a special onion sauce and sauerkraut.

Another place not to miss is Nathan’s Famous at Coney Island, famous for their yearly hot dog eating contest. Their hot dogs have a unique spice mix and are served on a toasted bun.

Hot dogs became part of New York’s food scene in the late 1800s, thanks to German immigrants. They’ve since become a staple of New York’s street food, with many vendors adding their own special touch to the dish. You can have your hot dog with mustard, ketchup, sauerkraut, or a mix, and it will be a memorable part of your visit.

Deli Sandwiches

In the bustling streets of New York, the deli sandwich stands as a culinary icon, a testament to the city’s rich cultural tapestry woven by Jewish immigrants in the early 1900s. Their heirloom recipes gave rise to a food phenomenon that remains a beloved fixture to this day.

Take the pastrami on rye, for example. Imagine layers of succulent pastrami, expertly cured and peppered, stacked atop freshly baked rye bread. A smear of tangy mustard complements the meat, and the crunch of a pickle on the side completes the experience. It’s a dish steeped in New York tradition and savored for its robust flavors.

Exploring the city’s deli scene further, you’ll encounter regional twists, such as the corned beef sandwich. It’s a marvel of taste and texture, with melt-in-your-mouth corned beef, melted Swiss cheese, tangy sauerkraut, and creamy Russian dressing nestled between slices of rye. Then there’s the Reuben – similar to its corned beef cousin but with pastrami taking center stage alongside the Swiss cheese and sauerkraut.

Embarking on a New York deli adventure promises more than just a meal; it’s an authentic slice of the city’s gastronomic heritage. Each sandwich tells a story of generations, craftsmanship, and the melding of cultures. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, indulging in a New York deli sandwich is essential. It’s not merely food; it’s a bite of history, culture, and the heart of New York itself.


Cheesecake is a delightful dessert that pairs a smooth, velvety filling with a crunchy base made from graham crackers. It’s a favorite for those who love a rich and fulfilling dessert experience. In the diverse culinary landscape of New York, cheesecake lovers are spoiled for choice with an array of flavors available to please the palate.

Junior’s in Brooklyn has earned its reputation as a top destination for cheesecake enthusiasts. Their New York-style cheesecake stands out for its exceptional creaminess and well-rounded flavor — a genuine treat not to be missed by connoisseurs.

Meanwhile, Eileen’s Special Cheesecake in SoHo offers cheesecakes that are notable for their airy and delicate texture. They serve traditional vanilla as well as distinctive varieties such as pumpkin and red velvet.

For an innovative take on cheesecake, Two Little Red Hens on the Upper East Side is a noteworthy stop. Their selection spans from the tangy key lime to the rich chocolate peanut butter and the fruity raspberry swirl. These cheesecakes strike an excellent harmony of taste, with each bite bringing a satisfying sweetness.

When indulging in New York’s cheesecake scene, these venues illustrate the city’s commitment to quality and variety in baking. Their cheesecakes not only satisfy a sweet tooth but also reflect the culinary craftsmanship that New York is celebrated for.

Street Tacos

New York is renowned for its dynamic food scene, drawing in those who love good eats with its vast array of tasty offerings. The city’s bustling streets now boast a delicious trend: street tacos. Food trucks throughout New York City are dishing out some of the most authentic Mexican tacos around. Here’s a rundown of five street tacos that are a must-try, each promising a taste reminiscent of Mexico itself:

  • Carnitas Taco: This taco features pork that’s been slow-cooked until it’s exceptionally tender, marinated with a blend of spices that bring out its natural flavors, and finished with a zesty salsa verde. The pork’s succulence ensures every bite is unforgettable.
  • Al Pastor Taco: A delightful combination of thinly sliced pork, marinated and cooked on a vertical spit similar to how shawarma is prepared, this taco is garnished with sweet pineapple and fresh cilantro, creating an irresistible sweet-savory mix.
  • Barbacoa Taco: Enjoy the richness of beef that has been slow-cooked with a mix of spices, then coupled with crisp onions and cilantro. The beef’s smokiness and tenderness make this taco a standout.
  • Fish Taco: A warm tortilla envelops crispy battered fish, topped with a zesty slaw and a smooth chipotle sauce. The play of crunchy and creamy textures alongside the flavors makes this taco a crowd-pleaser.
  • Vegetarian Taco: For those looking for a plant-based option, this taco is filled with a variety of grilled vegetables like peppers, onions, and zucchini, all complemented with a generous serving of guacamole, offering a satisfying yet lighter fare.

New York invites you to a culinary journey right on its streets with these flavorful tacos. No matter your preference, meat-lover, or vegetarian, there’s a taco catering to your palate. Why not gather some friends, find the nearest food truck, and dive into the genuine flavors of Mexico in the heart of New York?

Did you like reading about the The Best Local Foods to Eat in New York?
Share blog post:

Read the complete travel guide of New York

Related articles about New York